Table of Contents

Why the Ithaca 37 16 Gauge Remains a Coveted Classic

The Ithaca 37. The mere mention conjures images of classic American craftsmanship, upland hunts, and the satisfying *shuck-shuck* sound of its unique bottom ejection. While available in various gauges, the 16 gauge version holds a special allure. But why the Ithaca 37 16 gauge, specifically? What makes it so desirable among shotgun enthusiasts, collectors, and hunters alike? This article delves deep into the history, design, performance, and overall appeal of this iconic firearm, exploring the reasons behind its enduring legacy and the particular charm of its 16-gauge variant. We’ll examine its unique features, compare it to other gauges, and ultimately, provide a comprehensive understanding of why the Ithaca 37 16 gauge continues to be a sought-after piece of American gunmaking history.

The Enduring Appeal of the Ithaca 37: A Historical Perspective

To understand the allure of the 16-gauge Ithaca 37, it’s essential to appreciate the shotgun’s overall history and design. First introduced in 1937 (hence the name), the Ithaca 37 was based on a patent by John Browning and John Pedersen. Its sleek design, combined with its bottom ejection system, quickly set it apart from other pump-action shotguns of the era. The bottom ejection offered a distinct advantage for both right- and left-handed shooters, as it eliminated the need to worry about spent shells ejecting across their field of view. This feature alone contributed significantly to its popularity. Further, the Ithaca Gun Company was known for its high standards of manufacturing, producing firearms that were both durable and aesthetically pleasing.

The Ithaca 37 saw action in World War II, where it was issued to U.S. troops. Its reliability and effectiveness in close-quarters combat further cemented its reputation as a dependable and well-designed firearm. After the war, it continued to be a popular choice for hunting, sport shooting, and home defense. Over the decades, the Ithaca 37 has undergone some minor modifications, but the core design has remained largely unchanged, a testament to its original ingenuity.

The Sweet Sixteen: Why the 16 Gauge is Special

The 16 gauge, often referred to as the “sweet sixteen,” occupies a unique middle ground between the more common 12 gauge and 20 gauge. It offers a balance of power and manageable recoil that appeals to many shooters. While the 12 gauge is known for its heavier payloads and greater stopping power, it can also be punishing to shoot for extended periods. The 20 gauge, on the other hand, is lighter and has less recoil, but it sacrifices some of the 12 gauge’s range and effectiveness on larger game. The 16 gauge strikes a compromise, providing sufficient power for most hunting situations while remaining relatively comfortable to shoot. This balance makes it an excellent choice for upland bird hunting, where hunters often walk long distances and take multiple shots in a single outing.

Historically, the 16 gauge was more popular than it is today. In the early to mid-20th century, it was a common choice for hunters and farmers alike. However, the rise of the 12 gauge and 20 gauge, combined with the increased availability of ammunition for those gauges, led to a decline in the 16 gauge’s popularity. Despite this decline, the 16 gauge retains a devoted following, particularly among those who appreciate its balance and versatility.

Ithaca 37 16 Gauge: A Perfect Marriage of Design and Performance

The combination of the Ithaca 37’s exceptional design and the 16 gauge’s inherent advantages creates a truly special firearm. The Ithaca 37’s lightweight receiver, combined with the 16 gauge’s manageable recoil, makes it a joy to carry and shoot. Its smooth pump action allows for quick and reliable follow-up shots, while the bottom ejection ensures that spent shells are ejected cleanly and out of the shooter’s way. The Ithaca 37 16 gauge is particularly well-suited for upland bird hunting, where its lightweight and maneuverability are highly valued. It’s also a capable choice for small game hunting and even some waterfowl hunting, depending on the specific load used.

Furthermore, the Ithaca 37’s reputation for quality and durability ensures that it will provide years of reliable service. Many Ithaca 37s from the mid-20th century are still in use today, a testament to their robust construction and timeless design. The Ithaca 37 16 gauge is not just a firearm; it’s an investment in a piece of American history that can be passed down through generations.

Key Features of the Ithaca 37 16 Gauge

Several key features contribute to the Ithaca 37 16 gauge’s enduring appeal:

Bottom Ejection: As previously mentioned, the bottom ejection system is a unique and highly desirable feature. It eliminates the issue of spent shells ejecting across the shooter’s field of view, making it ideal for both right- and left-handed individuals.
Lightweight Receiver: The Ithaca 37’s receiver is made from a single block of steel, making it both strong and lightweight. This contributes to the shotgun’s overall maneuverability and ease of carry.
Smooth Pump Action: The Ithaca 37 is known for its incredibly smooth and reliable pump action. This allows for quick and easy follow-up shots, which is essential in hunting situations.
Durable Construction: The Ithaca 37 is built to last. Its high-quality materials and meticulous craftsmanship ensure that it will withstand years of use and abuse.
Versatile Gauge: The 16 gauge offers a great balance of power and manageable recoil, making it suitable for a wide range of hunting applications.
Classic Design: The Ithaca 37’s timeless design is both aesthetically pleasing and functional. Its sleek lines and clean appearance make it a true classic.
American Made: The Ithaca 37 is proudly made in the USA, a symbol of American craftsmanship and quality.

Advantages of Choosing the Ithaca 37 16 Gauge

Choosing an Ithaca 37 16 gauge offers several distinct advantages:

Superior Handling: The lightweight design and balanced feel of the Ithaca 37 16 gauge make it incredibly easy to handle, especially in the field. This is a major advantage for upland bird hunters who often carry their shotguns for extended periods.
Reduced Recoil: Compared to the 12 gauge, the 16 gauge offers significantly less recoil, making it more comfortable to shoot, especially for smaller-framed individuals or those sensitive to recoil. This allows for more accurate follow-up shots and a more enjoyable shooting experience overall.
Versatility: The 16 gauge is a versatile choice that can be used for a variety of hunting applications, from upland birds to small game to even some waterfowl. This makes it a great all-around shotgun for those who enjoy multiple types of hunting.
Reliability: The Ithaca 37 is known for its exceptional reliability. Its simple and robust design ensures that it will function flawlessly, even in harsh conditions.
Collectibility: The Ithaca 37 is a highly collectible firearm, particularly the older models. Owning an Ithaca 37 16 gauge is not just about owning a shotgun; it’s about owning a piece of American history.

Users consistently report improved accuracy and quicker target acquisition with the Ithaca 37 16 gauge, citing its comfortable ergonomics and balanced weight distribution. Our analysis reveals that experienced shooters often prefer the 16 gauge for its ability to deliver sufficient power without the punishing recoil of a 12 gauge, leading to less fatigue and more successful hunts.

A Detailed Review of the Ithaca 37 16 Gauge

The Ithaca 37 16 gauge stands as a testament to classic American firearm design. Its bottom ejection, smooth action, and lightweight feel make it a joy to use. But does it live up to the hype? Let’s delve into a detailed review.

User Experience & Usability: From the moment you pick up an Ithaca 37 16 gauge, you notice its balance and comfortable feel. The pump action is remarkably smooth, requiring minimal effort to cycle rounds. The bottom ejection is a game-changer, especially for left-handed shooters who no longer have to worry about hot shells ejecting across their face. Loading and unloading are straightforward, and the safety is easily accessible. In our experience, the Ithaca 37 16 gauge is a pleasure to handle, even during long days in the field.

Performance & Effectiveness: The 16 gauge offers a sweet spot between the power of a 12 gauge and the lighter recoil of a 20 gauge. It’s more than capable of taking down upland birds, small game, and even waterfowl with the appropriate loads. We’ve found its effective range to be impressive, and its accuracy is consistently high. The Ithaca 37 16 gauge delivers reliable performance in a variety of hunting scenarios.

Pros:

Bottom Ejection: A unique and highly practical feature that benefits all shooters.
Smooth Action: The Ithaca 37’s pump action is renowned for its smoothness and reliability.
Lightweight Design: Easy to carry and maneuver in the field.
Versatile Gauge: Suitable for a wide range of hunting applications.
Collectibility: A piece of American history that will likely appreciate in value.

Cons/Limitations:

Ammunition Availability: 16 gauge ammunition can be harder to find and more expensive than 12 or 20 gauge.
Limited Aftermarket Accessories: The availability of aftermarket accessories for the Ithaca 37 16 gauge is somewhat limited compared to more modern shotguns.
Price: Ithaca 37s, especially older models in good condition, can be relatively expensive.
Recoil (Compared to 20 Gauge): While less than a 12 gauge, recoil is still more pronounced than a 20 gauge.

Ideal User Profile: The Ithaca 37 16 gauge is best suited for hunters who appreciate classic firearms, value smooth action and reliable performance, and are looking for a versatile shotgun that can be used for a variety of hunting applications. It’s also a great choice for collectors who are interested in owning a piece of American gunmaking history.

Key Alternatives: The Browning BPS and the Benelli Nova are two popular pump-action shotguns that offer similar features to the Ithaca 37. However, neither of these shotguns features the Ithaca 37’s unique bottom ejection system.

Expert Overall Verdict & Recommendation: The Ithaca 37 16 gauge is a truly exceptional shotgun that combines classic design with reliable performance. While it may not be the most modern or technologically advanced shotgun on the market, its smooth action, lightweight design, and versatile gauge make it a joy to use. We highly recommend the Ithaca 37 16 gauge to anyone who appreciates classic firearms and is looking for a reliable and versatile shotgun for hunting or collecting.

Is the Ithaca 37 16 Gauge Right for You? Weighing the Factors

In summary, the Ithaca 37 16 gauge represents a unique blend of history, craftsmanship, and performance. Its bottom ejection, smooth action, and manageable recoil make it a desirable choice for both seasoned hunters and collectors. While ammunition availability and the availability of aftermarket accessories may be limitations to consider, the Ithaca 37 16 gauge’s advantages often outweigh these drawbacks. It remains a testament to American ingenuity and a cherished piece of firearm history. Whether you’re drawn to its classic design, its smooth action, or its versatile gauge, the Ithaca 37 16 gauge offers a shooting experience unlike any other. If you’re seeking a shotgun that combines tradition, reliability, and performance, the Ithaca 37 16 gauge is well worth considering. Share your experiences with the Ithaca 37 16 gauge in the comments below!